| Year |
Winner (Team, Position) |
| 2022 |
Terrian Rainey (First, Offensive Line) **OFFENSIVE LINEMAN OF THE YEAR** |
| |
Jalen Dunnigan (First, Wide Receiver) |
| |
Brian Jenkins (First, Wide Receiver) |
| |
Evan Leake (First, Running Back) |
| |
JT Price (First, Offensive Line) |
| |
Joshua Anderson (Second, Defensive Line) |
| |
Cameron Crouch (Second, Quarterback) |
| |
Jeremy Gesky (Second, Offensive Line) |
| |
Drew Hanft (Second, Linebacker) |
| |
Guillermo Chavarria-Flores (Honorable Mention, Defensive Line) |
| |
Alex Fish (Honorable Mention, Long Snapper) |
| |
Latrell Wade (Honorable Mention, Tight End) |
| 2021 |
Jason Freeman (First, Linebacker) **DEFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE YEAR** |
| |
Jalen Dunnigan (First, Wide Receiver, Second Special Teams) |
| |
Brian Jenkins (First, Wide Receiver) |
| |
Terrian Rainey (First, Offensive Line) |
| |
Andrew Ryczek (First, Special Teams) |
| |
Princeten Harris (First, Defensive Back) |
| |
Aaje Grayson (Second, Running Back) |
| |
Jared Honey (Second, Running Back/Tight End) |
| |
Shane O'Mara (Second, Offensive Line) |
| |
J.T. Price (Second, Offensive Line) |
| |
Scotty Graziano (Second, Wide Receiver) |
| |
Joshua Mathiasen (Second, Defensive Lineman) |
| |
Mark Phelps (Second, Linebacker) |
| |
Patryk Ryczek (Second, Defensive Back) |
| |
Grant Manke (Honorable Mention, Defensive Lineman) |
| |
Eric Cloy (Honorable Mention, Defensive Lineman) |
| |
Lance Walker (Honorable Mention, Safety) |
| 2020 |
David Hutton (First, Quarterback) **OFFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE YEAR** |
| |
Jason Freeman (First, Linebacker) **DEFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE YEAR** |
| |
Jalen Dunnigan (First, Wide Receiver, Second, Special Teams) |
| |
Jared Allen (First, Offensive Line) |
| |
Arinze Ekowa (First, Defensive Line) |
| |
Princeton Harris (First, Defensive Back) |
| |
Aaje Grayson (Second, Running Back) |
| |
Max McClendon (Second, Running Back) |
| |
Scotty Graziano (Second, Wide Receiver) |
| |
Terrian Rainey (Second, Offensive Line) |
| |
Daniel Brown (Second, Offensive Line) |
| |
Grant Manke (Second, Defensive Line) |
| |
Mark Phelps (Second, Linebacker) |
| |
Patryk Ryczek (Second, Linebacker) |
| |
Bryce DeGuira (Second, Kicker) |
| |
Lance Walker (Honorable Mention, Defensive Back) |
| |
Brian Jenkins (Honorable Mention, Wide Receiver) |
| |
Peyton Wuerch (Honorable Mention, Defensive Line) |
| 2019 |
Jared Allen (First, Offensive Line) |
| |
Josh Anderson (First, Punter) |
| |
Brody Crossin (Second, Linebacker) |
| |
Jayvion Daniels (First, Returner) |
| |
Jalen Dunnigan (Second, Wide Receiver) |
| |
Bryce DeGuira (Second, Kicker) |
| |
Jason Freeman (Honorable Mention, Linebacker) |
| |
Sean Galligar (First, Offensive Line) |
| |
Brian Jenkins (Honorable Mention, Wide Receiver) |
| |
Brandon Johnson (Honorable Mention, Offensive Line) |
| |
Jake Klingelsmith (Second, Tight End) |
| |
Jordan Lawton (Second, Quarterback) |
| |
T.J. Layne (Second, Defensive Line) |
| |
James Officer IV (First, Offensive Line) |
| |
Brock Perry (First, Defensive Back) |
| |
LaShaun Rule (Second, Running Back) |
| |
Patryk Ryczek (Second, Defensive Back) |
| |
Jalon Simpson (Second, Linebacker) |
| 2018 |
Jared Allen (Honorable Mention, Offensive Line) |
| |
Josh Anderson (First, Punter/Second, Kicker) |
| |
Davis Clay (Second, Offensive Line) |
| |
Caleb Coe (First, Linebacker) **DEFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE YEAR** |
| |
Brody Crossin (First, Linebacker) |
| |
Jayvion Daniels (First, Running Back) |
| |
Arinze Ekowa (First, Defensive Line) |
| |
Sean Galligar (Second, Offensive Line) |
| |
Rashaan Gaymon (First, Wide Receiver) |
| |
Jordan Lawton (Second, Quarterback) |
| |
T.J. Layne (Honorable Mention, Offensive Line) |
| |
James Officer IV (First, Offensive Line) |
| |
Jalon Simpson (Second, Linebacker) |
| |
Mason Southall (Honorable Mention) |
| 2017 |
Erik Anderson (First, Running Back) |
| |
Josh Anderson (First, Punter) |
| |
Zane Burtron (First, Offensive Line) |
| |
Caleb Coe (First, Linebacker) |
| |
Brody Crossin (Honorable Mention, Linebacker) |
| |
Seth Cunningham (Second, Defensive Back) |
| |
Arinze Ekowa (Second, Defensive Line) |
| |
Sean Galligar (Honorable Mention, Offensive Line) |
| |
Rashaan Gaymon (First, Wide Receiver) |
| |
T.J. Foulks (Honorable Mention, Defensive Line) |
| |
Jordan Lawton (Second, Quarterback) |
| |
Sebastian Swift (Second, Linebacker) |
| 2016 |
Erik Anderson (Honorable Mention, Running Back) |
| |
Caleb Coe (Second, Linebacker) |
| |
Rashaan Gaymon (Second, Wide Receiver) |
| |
Andrew Manganiello (Honorable Mention, Defensive Line) |
| |
Drew Philson (Honorable Mention, Defensive Back) |
| |
Dan Sullivan (Second, Offensive Line) |
| |
Sebastian Swift (Second, Linebacker) |
| 2015 |
Zane Burtron (Honorable Mention, Offensive Line) |
| |
Caleb Coe (Honorable Mention, Linebacker) |
| |
Thomas Dexter (First Team, Defensive Line) |
| |
Adam Glanders (Second, Wide Receiver) |
| |
Lucas Limberg (Second, Defensive Back) |
| |
Andrew Manganiello (Honorable Mention, Defensive Line) |
| |
Sebastian Swift (Second, Linebacker) |
| 2014 |
Chris Aschemann (Offensive Line) |
| |
Thomas Dexter (Defensive Line) |
| |
Ron France (Defensive Line) |
| |
Alan Knol (Offensive Line) |
| |
Lucas Limberg (Defensive Back) |
| |
Brandon Ruemler (Linebacker) |
| |
Tyler Swindle (Wide Reciever) |
| |
Chandler Tuckerman (Defensive Back) |
| 2013 |
Michael Ho-Lewis (Running Back) |
| |
Alan Knol (Offensive Line) |
| |
Mark Kosrow (Defensive Back) |
| |
Andrew Muzljakovic (P/K) |
| |
Brandon Ruemler (Linebacker) |
| 2012 |
Chad McDaniel (Offensive Line) |
| |
Andrew Muzljakovich (P/K) |
| |
David Payne (Running Back) |
| |
Brandon Ruemler (Linebacker) |
| 2011 |
Coleman Gidcumb (Offensive Line) |
| |
Josh Howells (Wide Receiver) |
| |
Nathan Schott (Linebacker) |
| 2010 |
Joe Carter, Jr. (Linebacker) |
| 2009 |
Lucas Burr (Defensive Line) |
| |
David Scherer (Tight End) |
| 2008 |
Lucas Burr (Defensive Line) |
| |
Travis Powers (Linebacker) |
| 2007 |
Zach Alexander (Punter) |
| |
Lucas Burr (Defensive Line) |
| |
Marshall Fraley (Running Back) |
| |
Jeremy Robinson (Linebacker) |
| |
Matt Soulia (Kicker) |
| 2006 |
Harrison Brewer (Offensive Line) |
| |
Alan Bufford (Wide Receiver) |
| 2005 |
Joey Lochner (Defensive Back) |
| |
Chad Ruzich (Offensive Line) |
| 2004 |
Joey Lochner (Defensive Back) |
| |
Chad Ruzich (Offensive Line) |
| 2003 |
Ben Richardson (Defensive Back) |
| |
Allen Swilley (Running Back) |
| |
Tim Vettel (Wide Receiver) |
| 2002 |
Allen Swilley (Running Back) |
| 2001 |
Terrence Streater (Running Back) |
| |
Sean Tinklenberg (Wide Receiver) |
| 2000 |
Ben Burke (Running Back) |
| |
David Evans (Defensive Line) |
| |
Isaac Johnson (Defensive Back) |
| |
Greg Murphy (Linebacker) |
| |
Ben Richardson (Defensive Back) |
| 1999 |
Pete Campbell |
| |
Jason Cornelius |
| |
Greg Reid |
| |
Bart Saudners |
| 1998 |
Steve Boelte |
| |
Damon Cornelius |
| |
Brian Fish |
| |
Jeff Knight |
| |
Brad Odgers |
| |
Greg Reid |
| |
Bart Saunders |
| |
Dave Spencer |
| 1997 |
Dan Adams |
| |
Hollist Brown |
| |
Ardel Buchanan |
| |
John Hoogendoom |
| |
Jeff Knight |
| |
Bruce Mann |
| |
Chad Martin |
| 1996 |
Mike Chitwood |
| |
Chris Hill |
| |
Darnell Howard |
| |
Jeff Knight |
| 1995 |
Nick Bernardi |
| |
Chris Hill |
| 1994 |
Nick Bernardi |
| |
Todd Farber |
| |
Mike Green |
| |
Joe Holland |
| |
Tom Livezey |