ONU Football All-MSFA Award Award Winners
| Year | Winner (Team, Position) |
| 2022 | Terrian Rainey (First, Offensive Line) **OFFENSIVE LINEMAN OF THE YEAR** |
| Jalen Dunnigan (First, Wide Receiver) | |
| Brian Jenkins (First, Wide Receiver) | |
| Evan Leake (First, Running Back) | |
| JT Price (First, Offensive Line) | |
| Joshua Anderson (Second, Defensive Line) | |
| Cameron Crouch (Second, Quarterback) | |
| Jeremy Gesky (Second, Offensive Line) | |
| Drew Hanft (Second, Linebacker) | |
| Guillermo Chavarria-Flores (Honorable Mention, Defensive Line) | |
| Alex Fish (Honorable Mention, Long Snapper) | |
| Latrell Wade (Honorable Mention, Tight End) | |
| 2021 | Jason Freeman (First, Linebacker) **DEFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE YEAR** |
| Jalen Dunnigan (First, Wide Receiver, Second Special Teams) | |
| Brian Jenkins (First, Wide Receiver) | |
| Terrian Rainey (First, Offensive Line) | |
| Andrew Ryczek (First, Special Teams) | |
| Princeten Harris (First, Defensive Back) | |
| Aaje Grayson (Second, Running Back) | |
| Jared Honey (Second, Running Back/Tight End) | |
| Shane O'Mara (Second, Offensive Line) | |
| J.T. Price (Second, Offensive Line) | |
| Scotty Graziano (Second, Wide Receiver) | |
| Joshua Mathiasen (Second, Defensive Lineman) | |
| Mark Phelps (Second, Linebacker) | |
| Patryk Ryczek (Second, Defensive Back) | |
| Grant Manke (Honorable Mention, Defensive Lineman) | |
| Eric Cloy (Honorable Mention, Defensive Lineman) | |
| Lance Walker (Honorable Mention, Safety) | |
| 2020 | David Hutton (First, Quarterback) **OFFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE YEAR** |
| Jason Freeman (First, Linebacker) **DEFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE YEAR** | |
| Jalen Dunnigan (First, Wide Receiver, Second, Special Teams) | |
| Jared Allen (First, Offensive Line) | |
| Arinze Ekowa (First, Defensive Line) | |
| Princeton Harris (First, Defensive Back) | |
| Aaje Grayson (Second, Running Back) | |
| Max McClendon (Second, Running Back) | |
| Scotty Graziano (Second, Wide Receiver) | |
| Terrian Rainey (Second, Offensive Line) | |
| Daniel Brown (Second, Offensive Line) | |
| Grant Manke (Second, Defensive Line) | |
| Mark Phelps (Second, Linebacker) | |
| Patryk Ryczek (Second, Linebacker) | |
| Bryce DeGuira (Second, Kicker) | |
| Lance Walker (Honorable Mention, Defensive Back) | |
| Brian Jenkins (Honorable Mention, Wide Receiver) | |
| Peyton Wuerch (Honorable Mention, Defensive Line) | |
| 2019 | Jared Allen (First, Offensive Line) |
| Josh Anderson (First, Punter) | |
| Brody Crossin (Second, Linebacker) | |
| Jayvion Daniels (First, Returner) | |
| Jalen Dunnigan (Second, Wide Receiver) | |
| Bryce DeGuira (Second, Kicker) | |
| Jason Freeman (Honorable Mention, Linebacker) | |
| Sean Galligar (First, Offensive Line) | |
| Brian Jenkins (Honorable Mention, Wide Receiver) | |
| Brandon Johnson (Honorable Mention, Offensive Line) | |
| Jake Klingelsmith (Second, Tight End) | |
| Jordan Lawton (Second, Quarterback) | |
| T.J. Layne (Second, Defensive Line) | |
| James Officer IV (First, Offensive Line) | |
| Brock Perry (First, Defensive Back) | |
| LaShaun Rule (Second, Running Back) | |
| Patryk Ryczek (Second, Defensive Back) | |
| Jalon Simpson (Second, Linebacker) | |
| 2018 | Jared Allen (Honorable Mention, Offensive Line) |
| Josh Anderson (First, Punter/Second, Kicker) | |
| Davis Clay (Second, Offensive Line) | |
| Caleb Coe (First, Linebacker) **DEFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE YEAR** | |
| Brody Crossin (First, Linebacker) | |
| Jayvion Daniels (First, Running Back) | |
| Arinze Ekowa (First, Defensive Line) | |
| Sean Galligar (Second, Offensive Line) | |
| Rashaan Gaymon (First, Wide Receiver) | |
| Jordan Lawton (Second, Quarterback) | |
| T.J. Layne (Honorable Mention, Offensive Line) | |
| James Officer IV (First, Offensive Line) | |
| Jalon Simpson (Second, Linebacker) | |
| Mason Southall (Honorable Mention) | |
| 2017 | Erik Anderson (First, Running Back) |
| Josh Anderson (First, Punter) | |
| Zane Burtron (First, Offensive Line) | |
| Caleb Coe (First, Linebacker) | |
| Brody Crossin (Honorable Mention, Linebacker) | |
| Seth Cunningham (Second, Defensive Back) | |
| Arinze Ekowa (Second, Defensive Line) | |
| Sean Galligar (Honorable Mention, Offensive Line) | |
| Rashaan Gaymon (First, Wide Receiver) | |
| T.J. Foulks (Honorable Mention, Defensive Line) | |
| Jordan Lawton (Second, Quarterback) | |
| Sebastian Swift (Second, Linebacker) | |
| 2016 | Erik Anderson (Honorable Mention, Running Back) |
| Caleb Coe (Second, Linebacker) | |
| Rashaan Gaymon (Second, Wide Receiver) | |
| Andrew Manganiello (Honorable Mention, Defensive Line) | |
| Drew Philson (Honorable Mention, Defensive Back) | |
| Dan Sullivan (Second, Offensive Line) | |
| Sebastian Swift (Second, Linebacker) | |
| 2015 | Zane Burtron (Honorable Mention, Offensive Line) |
| Caleb Coe (Honorable Mention, Linebacker) | |
| Thomas Dexter (First Team, Defensive Line) | |
| Adam Glanders (Second, Wide Receiver) | |
| Lucas Limberg (Second, Defensive Back) | |
| Andrew Manganiello (Honorable Mention, Defensive Line) | |
| Sebastian Swift (Second, Linebacker) | |
| 2014 | Chris Aschemann (Offensive Line) |
| Thomas Dexter (Defensive Line) | |
| Ron France (Defensive Line) | |
| Alan Knol (Offensive Line) | |
| Lucas Limberg (Defensive Back) | |
| Brandon Ruemler (Linebacker) | |
| Tyler Swindle (Wide Reciever) | |
| Chandler Tuckerman (Defensive Back) | |
| 2013 | Michael Ho-Lewis (Running Back) |
| Alan Knol (Offensive Line) | |
| Mark Kosrow (Defensive Back) | |
| Andrew Muzljakovic (P/K) | |
| Brandon Ruemler (Linebacker) | |
| 2012 | Chad McDaniel (Offensive Line) |
| Andrew Muzljakovich (P/K) | |
| David Payne (Running Back) | |
| Brandon Ruemler (Linebacker) | |
| 2011 | Coleman Gidcumb (Offensive Line) |
| Josh Howells (Wide Receiver) | |
| Nathan Schott (Linebacker) | |
| 2010 | Joe Carter, Jr. (Linebacker) |
| 2009 | Lucas Burr (Defensive Line) |
| David Scherer (Tight End) | |
| 2008 | Lucas Burr (Defensive Line) |
| Travis Powers (Linebacker) | |
| 2007 | Zach Alexander (Punter) |
| Lucas Burr (Defensive Line) | |
| Marshall Fraley (Running Back) | |
| Jeremy Robinson (Linebacker) | |
| Matt Soulia (Kicker) | |
| 2006 | Harrison Brewer (Offensive Line) |
| Alan Bufford (Wide Receiver) | |
| 2005 | Joey Lochner (Defensive Back) |
| Chad Ruzich (Offensive Line) | |
| 2004 | Joey Lochner (Defensive Back) |
| Chad Ruzich (Offensive Line) | |
| 2003 | Ben Richardson (Defensive Back) |
| Allen Swilley (Running Back) | |
| Tim Vettel (Wide Receiver) | |
| 2002 | Allen Swilley (Running Back) |
| 2001 | Terrence Streater (Running Back) |
| Sean Tinklenberg (Wide Receiver) | |
| 2000 | Ben Burke (Running Back) |
| David Evans (Defensive Line) | |
| Isaac Johnson (Defensive Back) | |
| Greg Murphy (Linebacker) | |
| Ben Richardson (Defensive Back) | |
| 1999 | Pete Campbell |
| Jason Cornelius | |
| Greg Reid | |
| Bart Saudners | |
| 1998 | Steve Boelte |
| Damon Cornelius | |
| Brian Fish | |
| Jeff Knight | |
| Brad Odgers | |
| Greg Reid | |
| Bart Saunders | |
| Dave Spencer | |
| 1997 | Dan Adams |
| Hollist Brown | |
| Ardel Buchanan | |
| John Hoogendoom | |
| Jeff Knight | |
| Bruce Mann | |
| Chad Martin | |
| 1996 | Mike Chitwood |
| Chris Hill | |
| Darnell Howard | |
| Jeff Knight | |
| 1995 | Nick Bernardi |
| Chris Hill | |
| 1994 | Nick Bernardi |
| Todd Farber | |
| Mike Green | |
| Joe Holland | |
| Tom Livezey |